IELTS Simon vs BAND9AI Writing Feedback
Platform comparison · May 2026
Direct answer
IELTS Simon (ielts-simon.com) is a free blog that teaches Writing structure, Task 1 overviews, and Task 2 essay types. BAND9AI is criterion-level AI scoring on your own timed essays—not lessons or templates. Simon explains how to write; BAND9AI shows which band descriptor you hit on your original under exam time. Many students need both—Simon for method, BAND9AI to catch TR and CC leaks Simon articles cannot see in your draft.
Blog method vs rubric mocks
Simon optimises lesson clarity and repeatable structures. BAND9AI optimises rubric diagnosis on timed originals. Neither replaces the other if you memorise templates but still miss prompt parts.
Simon strength Clear Task 1/2 frameworks, free worked examples
BAND9AI strength TR/CC/LR/GRA bands on your essay text
Gap Reading Simon does not score your partial prompt coverage
When to choose which
| Your situation | Better fit |
|---|---|
| New to Task 1/2 structure | IELTS Simon blog lessons |
| Know method, stuck at Band 6–6.5 | BAND9AI criterion checks |
| Memorised Simon template, low TR | Rubric AI on fresh prompts |
Combined workflow (recommended)
- Study one Simon lesson type (e.g. agree/disagree).
- Write a timed essay without copying phrases.
- Submit to BAND9AI; fix one criterion leak.
- Repeat on a new prompt; validate on human mock.
- Compare more tools: best AI IELTS tools.
Key takeaways
- Simon = Writing method; BAND9AI = rubric diagnosis on timed originals.
- Templates without prompt-specific TR still cap at Band 6.
- Combine Simon lessons with weekly scored essays.
- Validate with human mocks before paying exam fees again.
FAQ
Simon teaches method well; you still need rubric scoring on your own timed essays to find TR and CC leaks.
No—combine Simon lessons with weekly timed essays scored on full criteria.
Memorised structure without prompt-specific TR still caps scores—AI shows which criterion failed.
Score one timed essay—see if Simon structure actually hits TR on a new prompt.
Get IELTS Reality Check →